Broiling, Take One: Grilled Cheese

Today begins my first “Two-Week Technique” challenge.  Because of my recent disappointment with broiled chicken (my first ever experience with a broiler), I want to broil a variety of foods to get a better feel for the process.  I have three recipes lined up and I figured I’d start with the easiest and work my way up to (what I imagine will be) the most difficult.  First up?  Grilled cheese!

First, and most importantly, I did do my research.  I compiled a list of the important things there are to know about broiling:

  • To broil is “to cook food a measured distance below direct, dry heat” (Better Homes and Gardens New Cookbook, 14th edition)
  • Use a ruler to measure the distance between the top of the food and the heating element; when cooking meat, the thinner the cut, the closer it should be to the heat source
  • Trim off excess fat to avoid flareups
  • Keep an eye on the food while it is cooking, as it can easily be overcooked if not watched carefully
  • Steer clear of oily marinades; for broiling, rubs are a better flavoring option
  • Meat should be at room temperature when you begin broiling

Until I found a recipe on Betty Crocker’s website for broiled grilled cheese, I didn’t know the broiler could be used to make something as simple as a cheese sandwich.  I tossed my superb grilled-cheese-making skills aside and put my broiler to the test.  First, I readied my bread and cheese while the broiler preheated.

The first hiccup I encountered was that the recipe didn’t specify whether to broil the sandwiches on “high” or “low.”  I did some quick reading online and found that many people used the low setting if they weren’t cooking a big slab of meat.  I decided to play it safe and broil the sandwiches on low.  I hardly took my eyes off of them, checking them about every ten seconds.  The recipe’s instructions were to broil them for two minutes on one side, flip them, and broil for one more minute.  I had to flip mine three different times over the course of five or six minutes.  Maybe low wasn’t the right call.  The good news is, they looked like your average grilled cheese!

Even though the broiled grilled cheese was successful, I don’t think I’ll do it again.  It gave the bread a different texture than what you’d get if you grilled them on a skillet.  But I had a good bonding moment with my broiler tonight and I’m excited for our next rendezvous:  Stuffed Potatoes with Ham, Thyme, and Gruyere!


8 thoughts on “Broiling, Take One: Grilled Cheese

    • The open vs. closed oven door debate has me very confused! Some sources are saying it’s a must to leave it open and some are saying it doesn’t matter either way. Other than reducing the risk of flareups, is there another reason to leave it open?


  1. Leaving the door open makes it easier to peek in every 10 seconds. 😉
    I am really enjoying your “new techniques” series – fun idea. I have to confess, as much as I cook, and for as long as I have been cooking, I rarely use the broiler. Exceptions are for a nice fish fillet, particularly salmon, or to crisp / melt something at the last stages of cooking (suc as breadcrumb-topped Mac and cheese). Anyway, that’s just me. Keep on trying new stuff, Hope. It’s fun!


  2. Pingback: Broiling final exam and experimental marinara meatballs | Me Cook Yummy One Day

  3. Try toasting the bread, then add a little butter, and then the cheese. Use a medium to sharp cheddar, adding several layers, then under the broiler till it bubbles. I eat it with a knife and fork.



Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s